Minnesota Invasive Terrestrial Plants and Pests Center
1992 Folwell Ave, St. Paul, MN 55108
How Goat-Grazing Research is Helping with Buckthorn Control
by Caro Silvola
July 17, 2019
Goat-grazing has been gaining popularity in the last decade as private landowners and public parks look for sustainable solutions to clearing buckthorn and other invasive plants. However, there has been very little research to document the effectiveness of goat-grazing or its consequences on plant communities.
Researchers are now catching up with the trend to provide data-driven direction to managers. A cross-disciplinary team – led by Tiffany Wolf of the Department of Veterinary Population Studies and Dan Larkin of the Department of Fisheries, Wildlife and Conservation Biology – is working the case from all angles. Their work will measure the impact of goat-grazing on buckthorn and native plant growth, and also address a deadly brain parasite that puts goats in the field at risk.
Researcher Katie Marchetto collects a plant sample in the field as part of her work on the effect of goat-grazing in invasive buckthorn control (Credit: Katie Marchetto)
Data-driven management
Post-doctoral researcher Katie Marchetto has taken the lead in site management and tracking the goats’ impact on buckthorn growth.
“I noticed that people were curious about the effects the goats were having on plant management and when they can and cannot be used,” said Marchetto. “Like me, they were seeing herds being used on public land and wanted to know more.”
One of the first questions to tackle was the basic issue of efficacy. What long-term impact does goat-grazing have on buckthorn growth, and how can it be optimized? Marchetto is seeking an answer with a population growth model, which doesn’t currently exist for buckthorn.
“I noticed that people were curious about the effects the goats were having on plant management and when they can and cannot be used.”
“Some of the things you can do with this type of model is actually see in different populations, which life stages are the most vulnerable to impact. ” said Marchetto, “What age of buckthorn or size of buckthorn should we be really going after to control the population?”
Marchetto’s colleague in the project Sara Nelson, a Master’s candidate in the Department of Conservation Biology, also emphasized the importance of tracking the impact of buckthorn control methods on native vegetation.
“In the restoration community the problem of buckthorn is particularly tricky, as it takes a lot of money and a lot of work,” she said. “It's important to think about what kind of vegetation will replace the buckthorn, and if different management techniques are better or worse at facilitating the recovery of a healthy plant community.”
Community dispatch
Goat Dispatch, a goat-rental based land management company based in Faribault, Minnesota, has been an essential partner in multiple aspects of the team’s research. Owner Jake Langeslag has allowed the team access to his own herd and facilitated communication with his customers for additional research field sites.
Goat Dispatch got its start the day Langeslag decided to rent six goats from his neighbor as an experiment to try and clear his own land of buckthorn.
“I was blown away by how willingly the goats ate the buckthorn, the fun they seemed to be having, and the low hassle once the set-up was complete,” he said.
This led to the development of his own herd for small-scale experiments, which soon caught the attention of nearby landowners.
“The next thing I know, we're running 400 goats all over the metro and full-time goat wrangling is our main family business,” said Langeslag.
Langeslag is no stranger to research himself. As a graduate of Minnesota State University of Mankato with a B.S. in ecology, he sees the involvement of researchers as a natural progression.
“I seriously missed scientific research and found myself wishing there was a University student who could test things in an official capacity when Katie reached out,” he said.
A buckthorn research plot before (left) and after (right) goat-grazing taken by post-doctoral researcher Katie Marchetto as part of her collaborative work with Goat Dispatch owner Jake Langeslag's herds. (Credit: Katie Marchetto)
Langeslag also views research as critical to his operation's credibility.
"Early on, I was getting some pushback," he said. "People were asking ‘How do we know what you’re doing is good?' And I would say, ‘Well, this is what I see in before and after images.' But we really want data, we want research data. So this works out as a really good partnership.”
“People were asking, 'How do we know what you're doing is good?' And I would say, 'Well, this is what I see in before and after images.' But we really want data, we want research data."
Between running a bustling business and raising a family, Langeslag has also helped found the Ecological Service Livestock Network in partnership with the USDA and Sustainable Farming Association. Formed out of a gathering of fellow Minnesota goat herders, he hopes this new field will grow through collaboration and the sharing of research.
“Even though we're all in ‘competition’, we still talk to each other. We're just really trying to grow the business, you know?” he said, “If you can't do a job for some reason, you let someone know who's closer. We help each other.”
His customers are also benefiting from the researchers' involvement.
“Homeowners love having someone there checking things out, because they like to know about what we’re finding,” said Langeslag. “If we find stuff worth sharing, we’ll share that data with them so they can see how it works.”
Goat Dispatch owner Jake Langeslag presents an overview of using goats to graze brush and invasive plants in a YouTube video. Langeslag is collaborating with MITPPC researchers by allowing his herds to be used in research about goat-grazing and buckthorn control. (Credit: Still image frame from Goat Dispatch YouTube Channel, Jake Langeslag)
Seeds of discovery
One of the team’s most recent breakthroughs came out of an experiment to track seed viability through the digestive system of a goat.
“At outreach events, people were seriously concerned that goats eating the buckthorn fruit may be dispersing seeds between sites,” said Marchetto.
These concerns drove researchers to create a small-scale experiment. This involved diapering a few goats, and examining the amount and growth potential of seeds that passed successfully through the goats’ digestive system.
“We were surprised to find that only a small percentage of the seeds they ingest come out the other end. Of those seeds, very few are viable and able to germinate,” said Marchetto.
Marchetto’s study filled in an information gap for managers like Langeslag and sprout hope for the growing industry.
“This was a huge discovery for land managers. I really see this being a big management tool to stop the buckthorn seed cycle."
“This was a huge discovery for land managers,” said Langeslag. “I really see this being a big management tool to stop the buckthorn seed cycle. No one really knew the germination impact before this.”
P. tenuis is a deadly parasite that affects goat herds. It is hosted and transmitted by snails that may be present on buckthorn and other plants goats enjoy grazing. Geese and other poultry are not susceptible to the parasite. (Figure provided by Katie Marchetto)
Kids, Meet Poultry
While the future looks bright for goat-grazing, there is one potential set-back for managers.
Parastronguloides tenuis is a deadly snail-and-slug-born parasite that causes slow neurological damage to goats, leading to paralysis and often death. When Langeslag was first getting his business off the ground he lost about 20-30 of his herd to the parasite.
“It’s just a really tough thing to watch. They get paralysis in their back legs and they start dragging and everything else in their body is fine but they just kind of slowly die,” said Langeslag. “And there are some treatments you can give them, but they just are never the same. In my mind, it’s the biggest derailment to the cause.”
Unlike goats and other mammals, birds are not susceptible to P. tenuis. Some have therefore suggested the introduction of poultry as a strategy for managing the risk of parasitic infection in herds. By feeding on the slugs and snails that serve as intermediary hosts to P. tenuis, poultry like ducks and geese could reduce the transmission of the parasite to grazing animals.
However, research-backed data on the effectiveness of this strategy to date has been limited. The team will actually be the first to test this method on a goat-grazing system.
Wolf, the team’s lead, has studied the paralysis-causing meningeal worm in Minnesota moose populations for years.
“Exploring the role of geese and ducks as an approach to mitigating transmission to pastured livestock like goats and alpacas is a great alternative to the only other means of mitigation and control that we have, which is using anti-parasitic drugs,” she said. “We know that overusing those can cause resistance to those drugs in other parasitic worms, which also impact the health of the livestock infected.”
Katie Marchetto tweets a video of the ducks raised by Dakota County 4-H students and their
families for invasive species research. (Credit: @GreenWorldHypo)
Wolf and her team have teamed up with the Dakota County 4-H for poultry expertise. Families within the project will raise and train ducklings for the pre-grazing strategy. UMN Extension and County 4-H Program Coordinator Anja Johnson has helped connect the project with excited families.
“I think it’s an amazing opportunity for the kids. We often talk about higher implementation, and having them involved provides a great experience in exploration and hands-on learning,” she said.
“I think it's an amazing opportunity for the kids. We often talk about higher implementation, and having them involved provides a great experience in exploration and hands-on learning."
Johnson hopes to visit one of the sites with some of the participating families and make the most of this experiential learning opportunity.
“Invasive plants can have far-reaching effects in regard to the diseases that they host and how they can impact our local agricultural crops and native plant communities,” said Wolf. “But we’re also taking a step back and thinking about, what are the disease risks to the goats while we’re employing them for the improvement of our plant communities? Considering all of the different tendrils that emerge from this project – I think it’s a great example of ecosystem health research.”
Funding for this project was provided by the Environment and Natural Resources Trust Fund as recommended by the Legislative Citizen Commission on Minnesota Resources.
This research project is scheduled to end in 2022. Find more information and project updates at the official project page.
Also check out our 'Meet the Researcher' Q+A features with project researchers Sara Nelson and Katie Marchetto.
About the Author
Caro Silvola is a Communications Intern with the Minnesota Invasive Terrestrial Plants and Pests Center (MITPPC). She is a double major in Bioproducts & Biosystems Engineering and English Literature and is highlighting research-community partnerships in the summer of 2019. Outside of the office, Caroline likes biking, making art, exploring, volunteering in her community and participating in environmental movement spaces.